Scaling Recruitment Efforts Without Compromising Quality: A Guide for TA Leaders

A smarter way to hire, without breaking the bank.

Hiring is expensive. The average cost per hire is $4,700, according to SHRM, but that’s just the beginning. When you factor in lost productivity, bad hires, and ramp-up time, the real cost can be three to four times an employee’s salary.

For Heads of Talent Acquisition, the challenge is clear: cut hiring costs without cutting corners. You need the best people, but you also need a process that’s lean, efficient, and scalable.

That’s where we come in. At Popp, we help teams hire smarter—without relying on adding headcount. Here’s how you can do the same.

1. Stop Paying for External Recruiters You Don’t Need

Agency fees are one of the biggest hiring expenses. Recruiters typically charge 15-30% of a candidate’s first-year salary, which means hiring a $100,000 employee can cost an extra $15,000 to $30,000 in fees alone.

Sometimes agencies make sense, but for most roles, building a strong, cost-effective hiring process in-house is a better investment.

What to do instead:

• Invest in your own sourcing tools—LinkedIn Recruiter, AI-driven platforms, or a talent pipeline strategy
• Use hiring tech (like Popp) to automate and streamline the process
• Leverage referrals—more on that below

For companies hiring 50 mid-level employees at $100,000 each, reducing agency dependence could save anywhere from $750,000 to $1.5 million annually.

‍2. Lean into Employee Referrals

‍Your best recruiters are your own employees.Referred candidates get hired 55% faster and are 46% more likely to stay for three years or more. That means lower turnover, fewer bad hires, and less money wasted.Instead of spending heavily on job ads, build a structured referral program that works:

• Offer real incentives—bonuses, charitable donations, or meaningful experiences
• Make referring easy—streamlined submission, fast feedback loops
• Recognise great referrers publicly to encourage participation

This approach helps companies cut sourcing time, reduce turnover, and save anywhere from $15,000 to $25,000 per bad hire avoided.

‍3. Fix Your Job Descriptions

‍Many hiring teams waste hours sifting through unqualified candidates—often because the job description was unclear from the start.Most job postings are too vague, too long, or filled with corporate jargon. Instead of attracting the right people, they just attract more people, many of whom aren’t a great fit.What to do instead:

• Write how you talk. Keep it clear and direct.
• Cut unnecessary requirements. Focus on skills over credentials.
• Use inclusive language to widen the talent pool.

Fewer irrelevant applications mean less time wasted and shorter hiring cycles, which directly impacts cost savings.

‍4. Automate the Boring Stuff

‍Recruiters spend about a third of their time on repetitive admin—scheduling, screening, follow-ups. That’s time that could be better spent actually hiring.With Popp, companies can automate where it makes sense, so talent teams can focus on people, not paperwork.Some ways to streamline hiring:

• AI-powered screening tools to surface top candidates
• Automated scheduling to move candidates through the pipeline faster
• Real-time hiring analytics to make better decisions

Companies that automate key hiring tasks often cut time-to-hire in half, filling roles faster, reducing costs, and easing recruiter workload. Reducing manual tasks by even 30% can save about $30,000 per recruiter annually.

‍5. Build an Employer Brand That Attracts the Right People

‍The best way to reduce hiring costs? Create a company people want to work for.Seventy percent of candidates research a company before applying. If they don’t like what they see—unclear values, outdated hiring practices, no transparency—they’ll move on. That means more effort (and money) spent trying to convince them.What to do instead:

• Showcase your company culture through real employee stories, behind-the-scenes content, and transparent job postings
• Make salaries, career growth opportunities, and DEI efforts visible to job seekers
• Engage with candidates where they are—social media, industry events, and direct outreach

Companies with strong employer brands spend less on job ads, have shorter hiring cycles, and retain employees longer, all of which reduce costs in the long run.

‍The Bottom Line

‍Cutting hiring costs isn’t about doing less—it’s about doing it better.

• Move away from expensive external recruiters and build in-house hiring strength
• Use referrals to find and retain great talent
• Write job descriptions that attract the right candidates from the start
• Automate the repetitive tasks so recruiters can focus on hiring
• Build an employer brand that makes people want to apply

At Popp, we help talent teams hire faster, smarter, and without the unnecessary overhead. If you’re rethinking your hiring strategy, let’s talk.Want to see how it works? Book a quick demo—no pressure, just smart hiring.

When it comes to talent acquisition, one size certainly doesn’t fit all. Whether you’re hiring a junior marketer or a seasoned data scientist, every candidate brings unique skills, experiences, and motivations to the table. So why would your recruitment strategy treat them all the same?

Personalisation has become more than just a nice-to-have in today’s competitive hiring landscape—it’s a necessity. Candidates want to feel seen, valued, and understood, and companies that deliver on these expectations are winning the war for talent.

Here’s why personalisation matters, how it improves hiring outcomes, and some practical strategies to get it right.

Why Personalisation in Recruitment Matters

1. Candidates Expect It

We live in an era where personalisation is everywhere—from Netflix recommendations to Spotify playlists. Unsurprisingly, candidates expect the same level of tailored experience during their job search.

A recent study by Talent Board found that 72% of candidates are more likely to engage with job opportunities that feel personalised to them. In the UK, research from Totaljobs revealed that 67% of job seekers are more likely to apply for a role if the communication feels tailored to their skills and experience.

2. It Boosts Candidate Engagement

Generic outreach often falls flat. Think of those bland, one-size-fits-all messages clogging up inboxes. On the other hand, personalisation grabs attention and fosters meaningful connections.

LinkedIn’s global recruitment report shows that personalised InMails are 45% more likely to be opened than generic ones, and the response rate increases by 20%. When candidates feel that an opportunity aligns with their goals, they’re more inclined to take the next step.

3. It Improves Hiring Outcomes

The benefits of personalisation extend beyond engagement. Companies that personalise tailored communication report better hiring outcomes, including faster time-to-hire and higher-quality candidates.

A McKinsey report highlights that organizations that personalise candidate experiences are 40% more likely to attract high-performing talent. This is particularly critical in industries where competition for skilled workers is fierce.

Strategies for Implementing Personalisation in Talent Acquisition

1. Craft Tailored Outreach Messages

Start by ditching generic templates. Instead of sending the same email to hundreds of candidates, tailor your messaging to highlight:

• How their skills align with the role.
• Why your company is a great fit for their career aspirations.
• Specific projects or initiatives they might find exciting.

For example, if you’re reaching out to a software developer, reference a recent project they shared on LinkedIn or a technology they’ve mastered. A small effort can make a big impact.

2. Use AI to Gain Insights

AI tools like Popp can analyse candidate profiles and surface insights that recruiters might otherwise miss. This includes:

• Skills and experience that align with job requirements.
• Patterns in career progression to predict cultural fit.
• Interests or achievements that can inform personalised outreach.

By leveraging AI, recruiters can focus on building relationships while technology handles the heavy lifting of data analysis.

3. Personalise Follow-Ups

Engagement doesn’t stop after the first touchpoint. Personalised follow-ups show candidates you’re genuinely interested. Here’s how to do it right:

• Reference your previous conversations or their responses.
• Provide updates tailored to their application status.
• Share relevant content, like blog posts or case studies, based on their interests.

For instance, if a candidate expressed interest in your company’s sustainability efforts, follow up with details about your latest green initiatives.

4. Tailor the Interview Experience

Personalisation shouldn’t stop once candidates enter the interview phase. Make the experience unique to them by:

• Aligning interview questions with their expertise.
• Connecting them with team members who share similar interests or career journeys.
• Offering flexibility in scheduling to accommodate their needs.

How Popp Enables Personalisation at Scale

While personalisation might sound labor-intensive, platforms like Popp make it manageable—even for high-volume hiring. Here’s how Popp helps:

• Automated Personalisation: Popp uses AI to craft tailored messages based on candidate profiles, saving recruiters time while ensuring every interaction feels personal.
• Real-Time Insights: Access actionable data about candidate preferences and skills to inform your approach.
• Engagement Tracking: Monitor which messages resonate most with candidates, refining your strategy over time.

With tools like Popp, recruiters can deliver a personalised experience without compromising on efficiency, making it easier to connect with the right talent, faster.

The Bottom Line

In a world where personalisation drives everything from customer loyalty to online engagement, it’s time for talent acquisition to follow suit. Tailored communication isn’t just about making candidates feel good—it’s about standing out in a crowded market and achieving better hiring outcomes.

By implementing personalisation strategies and leveraging tools like Popp, your team can build stronger connections with candidates, improve hiring efficiency, and ultimately win the race for top talent.

It’s time to leave generic recruiting in the past and embrace a more human, personalised approach.

‍

Recruitment automation and AI tools have been making waves in the talent acquisition world for years. But with innovation comes plenty of misconceptions, and automation in hiring is no exception.

From fears about AI replacing human recruiters to concerns about depersonalised candidate experiences, there’s a lot of noise out there. The truth? Recruitment automation isn’t here to steal jobs or strip away the human touch—it’s here to empower recruiters, making them more efficient and strategic.

Let’s break down the most common myths about recruitment automation and uncover what it really means for talent acquisition leaders.

Myth 1: “AI Will Replace Recruiters”

This is probably the biggest misconception about recruitment automation. Yes, AI is powerful, but it’s not replacing recruiters anytime soon.

The Reality

AI doesn’t eliminate jobs—it eliminates inefficiencies. Tools like Popp automate repetitive, time-consuming tasks like resume screening, interview scheduling, and follow-up emails. This frees up recruiters to focus on what they do best: building relationships, understanding team dynamics, and making strategic decisions.

According to a 2023 report by the CIPD, 73% of HR leaders in the UK agree that automation enhances, rather than replaces, human roles. Across the pond in the US, LinkedIn data shows that 81% of recruiters believe AI will make their jobs easier by automating administrative tasks.

Myth 2: “Automation Creates a Cold, Impersonal Candidate Experience”

Some worry that introducing automation into recruitment means sacrificing the personal touch candidates expect. But the opposite is often true.

The Reality

Automation can actually improve the candidate experience by ensuring timely, consistent communication and freeing up recruiters to spend more time engaging directly with candidates. For example, AI-powered chatbots provide instant answers to FAQs, while automated workflows ensure no candidate falls through the cracks.

Research from PwC reveals that 49% of UK job seekers say they’ve been ghosted by a potential employer, while 78% of candidates are more likely to apply again if they receive timely updates. Automation solves this by maintaining communication momentum.

Take Sense, a competitor platform, which uses automation to send personalised check-ins at key stages of the hiring process. Popp goes a step further by integrating automation into a centralised system, ensuring a seamless blend of human interaction and efficiency.

Myth 3: “AI Can’t Match Human Judgment”

Another common myth is that AI lacks the nuance to make fair or strategic hiring decisions.

The Reality

AI isn’t here to replace judgment—it’s here to complement it. By analysing large volumes of data, AI can surface insights that human recruiters might overlook, like identifying patterns in candidate performance or spotting unconscious bias in job descriptions.

Phenom, for instance, uses AI to match candidates to roles based on their skills, but the final decision always rests with the recruiter. Similarly, Popp uses machine learning to prioritise top candidates, giving recruiters more time to focus on the critical “human” parts of hiring, like culture fit and team alignment.

And the results speak for themselves: McKinsey reports that companies leveraging AI in hiring see a 40% improvement in recruiter productivity and a 25% reduction in time-to-hire.

Myth 4: “Automation Only Works for High-Volume Hiring”

While automation is often associated with processing thousands of applications for entry-level or seasonal roles, it’s just as valuable in specialised and executive hiring.

The Reality

High-volume hiring isn’t the only game in town for automation. Tools like Popp are flexible enough to support tailored hiring strategies, automating parts of the process while leaving room for personalised touchpoints where they matter most.

For example, automation can handle preliminary outreach and scheduling for senior roles, allowing recruiters to spend more time on detailed candidate evaluations and stakeholder alignment. In the UK, Deloitte reports that 41% of companies using AI in recruitment improved their ability to attract niche talent pools.

Myth 5: “Automation Is Too Complex to Implement”

The idea of overhauling your recruitment process with new technology can feel overwhelming. Many TA leaders worry about steep learning curves and disruptive implementation periods.

The Reality

Modern recruitment automation platforms are designed to integrate seamlessly with existing tools and workflows. Whether it’s an applicant tracking system (ATS) or your internal collaboration tools, platforms like Popp focus on simplicity and ease of use.

Take Scotty AI, which requires significant upfront setup but offers limited flexibility. In contrast, Popp provides out-of-the-box functionality and intuitive design, enabling teams to get started in days, not months.

The proof? Gartner found that companies adopting user-friendly automation tools experienced a 50% faster implementation timeline compared to traditional systems.

Why Popp Is Different

At Popp, we don’t believe in a “one-size-fits-all” approach to recruitment automation. Our platform is built to:

• Empower Recruiters: Handle the admin so your team can focus on strategic hiring decisions.
• Enhance Candidate Experience: Keep candidates informed and engaged with seamless, timely communication.
• Scale with Your Needs: From high-volume hiring to bespoke executive searches, Popp adapts to your challenges.

By blending automation with a recruiter-first mindset, Popp ensures that technology complements—not competes with—your human expertise.

Final Thoughts

Recruitment automation isn’t something to fear—it’s something to embrace. By debunking these myths, it’s clear that AI and automation are not replacing recruiters but empowering them to work smarter, not harder.

The future of talent acquisition isn’t about choosing between technology and the human touch—it’s about finding the perfect balance. With tools like Popp, your team can achieve that balance and deliver a recruitment experience that’s efficient, engaging, and future-ready.

‍